Explain the Rationale for the Existence of Supplier Induced Demand in Health Care and Explore the Extent to Which Empirical Work Has Been Able to Establish Its Existence

Topics: Health economics, Health care, Medicine Pages: 13 (4401 words) Published: April 27, 2010


In the traditional market, consumers decide how much to consume and suppliers decide how much to supply and prices coordinate the decisions. For perfect competition it is assumed inter alia that there is: perfect information so that individuals are fully informed about prices, qualities etc; a lot of buyers and sellers; no single buyer or seller that has influence on the price. But health care market falls short of the perfect market paradigm as it is dogged by many phenomena that cause it to fail (Arrow 1963). One such phenomenon is supplier-induced demand (SID), whereby health care providers, usually physicians, exploit their information advantage over patients in order to induce patients to utilize more healthcare services than they would if they were accurately informed. The phenomenon of SID tends to take an important place within social debates because it has an impact on health care expenditures, health status and the allocation of income between patients and physicians (Labelle et al 1994). Therefore, it has attracted considerable attention in the health economics literature since Roemer (1961), who observed a positive correlation between the number of hospital beds available and their use leading to the observation, ‘a bed built is a bed filled’, sometimes referred to as Roemer’s Law. Although a variety of empirical tests of SID have been reported in literature, researchers disagree on the definition of and tests for SID. The validity of the results from the tests is controversial. Therefore there is no consensus on the development and implementation of public policy based on these results (Labelle et al 1994, p349). Indeed, Doessel (1995, p.58) observed that this area of research can be described as a theoretical and empirical quagmire. After defining the terms, this essay is going to explore and explain the theoretical rationale, the empirical evidence and policy implications for the existence of SID. The argument will be summed up in the conclusion.

Health Care Market and SID

A market is a shorthand expression for the process by which households’ decisions about consumption of alternative goods, firms’ decisions about what and how to produce, and workers’ decisions about how much and for whom to work are all reconciled by adjustment of prices. Health care comprises services of health care professionals, which are addressed at health promotion, prevention of illnesses and injury, monitoring of health, maintenance of health, and treatment of disease, disorders, and injuries in order to obtain cure or, failing that, optimum comfort and function (quality of life) (Worldbank website). In health care market there is: a few buyers and sellers; asymmetry of information therefore violation of consumer sovereignty; allocation of resources by physicians and not price mechanism etc. Therefore patients face a dilemma in translating their desire for good health into a demand for medical care. This requires both information and medical knowledge, which they usually do not have. There is no definitive and widely accepted definition of SID. In literature, the definitions range from positive and value free (Fuchs 1978) to normative with negative connotations (Folland et al 2001, p.204). McGuire (2000, p504) says that SID ‘exists when the physician influences a patient’s demand for care against the physician’s interpretation of the best interest of the patient’. Labelle et al (1994, p. 363) point out the need to incorporate in the definition of SID both the effectiveness of the agency relationship and the effectiveness of the induced services. This means that inducement can give rise to ‘good’ or ‘bad’ outcomes for patients depending on its clinical effectiveness, e.g. if a doctor persuades a patient to undertake more...

References: 1. Arrow, K. J. (1963). Uncertainty and the Welfare Economics of Medical Care. American Economic Review 53: 941-973.
2. Birch, S. (1988). The identification of supplier-inducement in a fixed price system of health care provision: The case of dentistry in the United Kingdom. Journal of Health Economics. 7:129–150.
3. Bunker, J. P. and Brown, B. W. (1974). The physician patient as an informed consumer of surgical services. New England Journal of Medicine 290: 1051-1055
5. Cromwell, J. and Mitchell J. (1986). Physician-Induced Demand for Surgery. Journal of Health Economics 5: 293-313.
6. Doessel, D.P. (1995). Commentary. In Harris, A. (ed), Economics and Health: 1994, Proceedings of the Sixteenth Australian Conference of Health Economists, School of Health Services Management, University of New South Wales, NSW.
7. Dranove, D. (1988). Demand inducement and the physician/patient relationship. Economic Inquiry 26:281-298
9. Evans, R. G. (1974). Supplier induced demand; some empirical evidence & implications. In Perlman, M. (ed). The economics of health & medical care. London: Macmillan
11. Folland, S., Goodman, A. and Stano, M. (2001). The Economics of Health and Health Care. 3rd ed, Upper Saddle River, New Jersey. Prentice Hall
13. Gaynor, M. (1994). Issues in the Industrial Organization of the Market for Physician Services. The Journal of Economics and Management Strategy 3(1): 211-255.
14. Goldberg, A.I. Cohen, G. and Rubin, A-H E. (1998). Physician Assessments of Patient Compliance with Medical Treatment. Social Science and Medicine 47(11): 1873-6)
16. Grytten, J. and Sorensen, R. (2001). Type of contract and supplier-induced demand for primary physicians in Norway. Journal of Health Economics 20: 379-393.
17. Grytten, J., Holst, D. and Laakf, P. (1990). Supplier Inducement: Its Effect on Dental Services in Norway; Journal of Health Economics 9: 483-491
19. Kenkel, D. (1990): Consumer health information and the demand for medical care. Review of Economics and Statistics 52: 587-595
21. Labelle, R., Stoddart, G. and Rice, T. (1994), A Re-examination of the Meaning and Importance of Supplier-Induced Demand. Journal of Health Economics 13(3): 347-368.
22. Manning, W. G., Jr. and Phelps, C. E. (1979). The demand for dental care. Bell Journal of Economics 10(2): 503–525.
23. McGuire, T. (2000 chapter 9). Physician agency. In Culyer, A. J. and Newhouse, J.P. (eds). Handbook of Health Economics, 1A, Elsevier: North Holland.
24. McGuire, T.G., and Pauly, M.V. (1991). Physician Response to Fee Changes with Multiple Payers. Journal of Health Economics 10: 385-410.
25. Reinhardt, U. (1989). Economists in health care: saviours, or elephants in a porcelain shop? American Economic Review 79: 337-342.
26. Rice, T. (1983). The Impact of Changing Medicare Reimbursement Rates on Physician-induced Demand. Medical Care. 21(8): 803-815.
27. Rice, T. (1984). Physician-induced demand: New evidence from the Medicare program. Advances in Health Economics and Health Services Research 6:129-160
29. Rizzo, J.A. and Blumenthal, D.A. (1996). Is the Target-Income Hypothesis an Economic Heresy? Medical Care Research and Review 53(3): 243–266.
30. Roch, D., Evans, R.G. and Pascoe, D. (1985). Manitoba and Medicare: 1971 to Present. Winnipeg, Manitoba: Manitoba Health.
31. Roemer, M.I. (1961). Bed supply and hospital utilisation: A national experiment, Hospitals. Journal of American Health Affairs 35:988–993
33. Sintonen, H. and Maljanen, T. (1995). Explaining the Utilisation of Dental Care: Experiences from the Finnish Dental Market. Health Economics 4(6): 453-466.
34. Tussing, A. D. and Wojtowycz, M. (1986). Physician-induced Demand by Irish General Practitioners’. Economic and Social Review 14(3): 225-247
36. Yip, W. (1998). Physician Responses to Medical Fee Reductions: Changes in the Volume and Intensity of Supply of Coronary, Artery Bypass Graft (CABG) Surgeries in the Medicare and Private Sectors, Journal of Health Economics 17(6): 675-699
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • HA HA HA HA Essay
  • The Existence of Vikings Research Paper
  • health care economics history Essay
  • Essay about Health Care Systems
  • Health Care Demands in Canada Essay
  • Essay on Evolution of Health Care
  • To what extent do judges establish the existence of a contract based on the intention of the parties? Essay
  • Essay about Modes of Existence

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free